On An Island

Far away on an island
I heard you whisper so close to me
Angel or devil, I will love you either way
You're cold and shifting like the swelling of the sea

And I, I love you more when you love me less
And I, I cannot help myself, so please forgive me

Far away on an island
I knew you only for a little while
The sea is the keeper of our secret now
And tells it only to the open sky

And I, I love you more when you love me less
And I, I cannot help myself, oh please forgive me
You're not to blame
Can't we start over again?